Updated Nov 22, 2026· 10 min read

Key takeaways

  • Rooftop cargo carriers add storage above the car for road trips and family travel with hard box, soft bag, and basket designs. Compare capacities.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A packed trunk is the classic road trip problem. Suitcases, camping gear, sports equipment, and the extras a family picks up along the way compete for the same limited space inside the car, and the passengers usually lose. A rooftop cargo carrier moves that overflow above the vehicle, freeing the cabin and the rear seats for the people actually riding in them.

Our top pick: Thule SideKick Rooftop Cargo Box. Runner-up: Yakima SkyBox 12 Carbonite.

Carriers come in three main forms. Hard shell boxes mount to crossbars, open on a hinged lid, and lock shut. Soft roof bags strap to rails, crossbars, or even a bare roof, then fold away when the trip ends. Roof baskets give you an open steel tray that pairs well with a weatherproof bag inside it.

This guide compares five rooftop carriers sold on Amazon: two hard boxes from Thule and Yakima, two soft bags from Rightline Gear and FIVKLEMNZ, and a basket and bag combination from MeeFar. Capacities run from 8 to 21 cubic feet, so there is a size for solo campers and for families loading up for a week away.

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a small commission from Amazon.

Thule SideKick Rooftop Cargo Box

See it on Amazon

The Thule SideKick is the compact entry in this lineup, a hard shell box built for smaller vehicles that still need extra room. It provides 8 cubic feet of storage, enough for camping gear or golf clubs, while its narrow footprint leaves space on the rack for other mounted accessories beside it.

The box opens from the passenger side, so you load and unload from the curb side of the vehicle rather than the traffic side. Mounting uses a U-bolt system that works with Thule rack systems, round bars, and most factory racks with horizontal crossbars, and the listing notes that installation and removal are quick once the hardware is in place.

Security comes from a cam locking system. The box ships with two camlocks and keys that secure the contents and lock the box itself to the carrier. Thule describes the shell as a heavy-duty design that protects gear and helps keep out the elements, and the listing prints a water resistance level of Water Resistant for this model.

Everything needed arrives in the carton: the cargo box, four U-bolts and brackets, four knobs, two camlocks with keys, vinyl hole covers, and the user manual. For drivers of compact cars who want a lockable hard box without covering the whole roof, the SideKick is the scaled-down option in this group.

Specs

  • Volume: 8 cubic feet
  • Exterior dimensions: 54 x 25 x 15.5 inches
  • Shell type: Hard
  • Mounting: U-bolt system for roof rack crossbars
  • Opening: Passenger side
  • Locks: Two cam locks included, securing contents and the box to the carrier
  • Included components: Cargo box and mounting hardware

Yakima SkyBox 12 Carbonite

See it on Amazon

The Yakima SkyBox 12 Carbonite stretches long and narrow, a shape that suits drivers who carry lengthy gear or who want to leave part of the roof free for a second mounted item. It holds 12 cubic feet and measures 92 inches long, 24 inches wide, and 16 inches tall, with a tapered design that Yakima says reduces hatch interference at the rear of the vehicle.

The lid opens from both sides, so loading works from whichever side of the car you parked against. Yakima builds the lid with a Carbonite textured finish and internal lid stiffeners for durability and easy opening and closing, and the listing describes the shape as aerodynamic, reducing drag and wind noise on the highway.

Locking is handled by the SuperLatch security system together with SKS locks, which the listing says keep the lid secure and gear safe inside. The box comes fully assembled, and the quick-release mounting hardware installs without tools. Per the listing, the universal mounting hardware fits all Yakima StreamLine crossbars plus factory and aerodynamic crossbars, with crossbar spreads of 24 to 42 inches.

At 41 pounds, the SkyBox 12 is a substantial box that most owners will mount with a second pair of hands. The listing prints a water resistance level of Water Resistant and a hard shell type for this model.

Specs

  • Volume: 12 cubic feet
  • Dimensions: 92 x 24 x 16 inches
  • Item weight: 41 pounds
  • Shell type: Hard
  • Opening: Dual-sided
  • Locks: SKS locks included with SuperLatch security system
  • Fit: Crossbar spreads of 24 to 42 inches, tool-free installation

Rightline Gear Sport 3 Rooftop Cargo Carrier

See it on Amazon

The Rightline Gear Sport 3 is a soft carrier with hard-box capacity: 18 cubic feet of storage, or 509 liters, in a bag that folds into its own stuff sack when the trip is over. For families who travel a few times a year and lack garage space for a rigid box, that fold-away storage is the main attraction.

Rightline Gear presents the Sport 3 as a waterproof carrier, pointing to its SZIP waterproof zipper as the feature behind that claim. The listing prints a water resistance level of Waterproof and a soft shell type, with a roof mount design that works in two ways.

With a roof rack, the included straps loop around the side rails or cross bars. Without a rack, the brand’s Car Clips hook under the door frame weather molding, and the clips can be attached or removed depending on the vehicle you are using that day. That flexibility makes the Sport 3 a fit for households that swap the carrier between two different cars.

The package includes the carrier, straps, clips, and a set up guide, and Rightline Gear backs the product with a one year warranty as printed on the listing. When the trip ends, the empty bag packs into the stuff sack and goes on a shelf instead of taking up floor space.

Specs

  • Volume: 18 cubic feet (509 liters)
  • Shell type: Soft
  • Water resistance level: Waterproof, per the listing
  • Closure: SZIP waterproof zipper
  • Attachment: Straps for roof rack rails or cross bars, or Car Clips for vehicles without a rack
  • Included components: Carrier, straps, clips, set up guide, and stuff sack
  • Warranty: One year, per the listing

MeeFar Roof Rack Basket and Cargo Bag Combo

See it on Amazon

MeeFar takes a different approach: an open steel basket on the roof, with a waterproof cargo bag that sits inside it. The basket measures 51 x 36 x 5 inches and is built from alloy steel with a black powder coated surface, and the listing gives the assembly a load capacity of 200 pounds.

The included bag adds 15 cubic feet of enclosed storage, measuring 44 x 34 x 17 inches, so loose gear rides protected inside the bag while the basket frame supports and contains the load. A cargo net and ratchet straps are part of the package, giving you a way to secure items placed directly in the basket as well.

Mounting uses U-bolts, and the listing describes the fit as universal for rooftop crossbars. This two-part layout suits campers and road trippers who alternate between bagged luggage one weekend and bulky, oddly shaped gear the next: use the bag for clothing and soft goods, then the open basket and net for the items that never fit inside a closed carrier.

The trade-off is assembly and weight: the listed item weight is 18.46 kilograms for the set. In return you get the most flexible loading arrangement of the five carriers in this guide.

Specs

  • Basket dimensions: 51 x 36 x 5 inches
  • Bag volume: 15 cubic feet (bag measures 44 x 34 x 17 inches)
  • Material: Alloy steel basket
  • Load capacity: 200 pounds
  • Mounting type: U-bolt, universal fit
  • Included components: Roof basket, waterproof cargo bag, cargo net, and ratchet straps

FIVKLEMNZ 21 Cubic Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Roof Bag

See it on Amazon

The FIVKLEMNZ roof bag offers the largest capacity in this lineup at 21 cubic feet, aimed at families who need maximum room on top of the vehicle. The listing presents it as a waterproof roof bag for the top of any vehicle, with or without a rack.

For rackless cars, six door hooks anchor the bag to the vehicle, and reinforced straps hold the load down. An anti-slip mat goes between the bag and the roof, keeping the carrier from shifting on the paintwork and giving the load a stable base. A luggage lock is included to secure the zipper closure.

Because it is a soft bag, the FIVKLEMNZ expands around what you pack rather than forcing your gear into a fixed shell shape, which helps with bulky items like duffels, sleeping bags, and sports kit. When the trip is over, it comes off the roof and stores flat, unlike a rigid box that needs a dedicated corner of the garage.

This is the pick for occasional long trips where capacity matters most and the car has no rack at all. For sheer volume per trip, the 21 cubic foot bag leads this group.

Specs

  • Volume: 21 cubic feet
  • Shell type: Soft
  • Fit: Vehicles with or without a roof rack
  • Included accessories: Anti-slip mat, reinforced straps, 6 door hooks, and luggage lock
  • Manufacturer part number: FIVKLEMNZ612

How to Choose a Rooftop Cargo Carrier

Start with your roof. Hard boxes and baskets need crossbars to mount to, so check whether your vehicle has rails and crossbars, rails only, or a bare roof. If you have no rack and no plans to add one, a soft bag with door hooks, like the Rightline Gear Sport 3 or the FIVKLEMNZ bag, is the direct route.

Next, match capacity to the trip. Solo campers and couples often manage with 8 to 12 cubic feet, the range of the Thule SideKick and Yakima SkyBox 12. Families loading for a week usually want 15 cubic feet or more, which points to the MeeFar bag, the Rightline Gear Sport 3, or the FIVKLEMNZ.

Check two measurements before ordering any hard box. The first is crossbar spread: the SkyBox 12, for example, fits spreads of 24 to 42 inches per its listing. The second is overall length against your hatch or trunk opening, since a long box can block a rear door that lifts upward. Also confirm your vehicle’s roof load limit in the owner’s manual and stay within the carrier’s printed load capacity.

Think about storage at home as well. Soft bags fold into a stuff sack or flat bundle. Hard boxes and steel baskets need floor or wall space between trips. Finally, consider locks: boxes with integrated locks secure both the gear and the carrier itself, while bags rely on a luggage lock at the zipper.

FAQ

Do rooftop cargo carriers require a roof rack?

Hard boxes and baskets do, because they clamp or bolt to crossbars. Soft bags are more flexible: models like the Rightline Gear Sport 3 and the FIVKLEMNZ bag attach to rails or crossbars when a rack is present and use door hooks or clips on the door frame when it is not.

How much weight can a rooftop carrier hold?

Each listing prints its own figure, such as 200 pounds for the MeeFar basket in this guide, but your vehicle’s roof load limit is the number that governs. Check the limit in the owner’s manual, add the weight of the carrier itself, and keep the total load under the lower of the two figures.

What is the difference between a hard box and a soft roof bag?

A hard box is a rigid shell with a hinged, lockable lid that mounts to crossbars and stays on the roof between trips. A soft bag is a flexible carrier that straps down, shapes itself around the load, and folds away for storage. Boxes offer built-in locks and a fixed shape; bags offer larger capacity and easier storage.

Can I leave a rooftop carrier on the car between trips?

Hard boxes are designed to stay mounted, and many owners leave them on for a season. Soft bags are quick to remove and are usually taken off after each trip, which also keeps the fabric out of constant sun and weather. Either way, empty the carrier before parking for long periods, and follow the care notes on the listing.

Conclusion

Each carrier here solves the same problem in a different way. The Thule SideKick suits small cars that need a compact lockable box, while the Yakima SkyBox 12 Carbonite adds dual-sided access and a long shape for drivers with crossbars already fitted. The Rightline Gear Sport 3 and the FIVKLEMNZ bag cover cars with or without a rack, at 18 and 21 cubic feet, and fold away when not in use. The MeeFar combo mixes open-tray flexibility with enclosed storage. Measure your roof, confirm your crossbar spread and load limit, and the right pick should be clear.

L
Linda Harper
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Best Rooftop Cargo Carriers for Road Trips and…Check price on Amazon

More from Amazon

Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

Amazon Wedding Registry

Collect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.

Create a wedding registry
Subscribe & Save

Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.

Explore Subscribe & Save
Amazon Prime

Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Start a Prime free trial
Audible

Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Try Audible free

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.